By Jason Ehlers
Help! I need some creative minds and some good ideas for a set of optional rules I'm writing! I'm working through some ideas for campaign rules for DBA historical miniatures. The centerpiece will be castles and sieges!
Here are the problems with the current rules for sieges (in my opinion):
In the current rules, it's too easy for the attacker to capture cities! It takes typically 1.5 seasons to capture and undefended city, and 2.5 seasons to capture a defended city! That's totally unrealistic! In fact, most fortifified cities were almost impossible to take by siege as long as they were properly provisioned until the invention of gunpoweder cannon. Solution: Make it more difficult for attackers to capture cities. Method: Unknown, as yet.
In the current rules, the defender is better off, game-wise, fighting OUTSIDE a supposedly "fortified" city! That may make for a faster campaing, but it is certainly not realistic! Solution: Make it advantageous for a defender to fight from a properly fortified city. Method: Unknown, as yet.
In the current rules, there is no way for the defender to improve city fortifications- except by placing his entire field army in jeopardy for an even chance of destroying a SINGLE enemy element! GRRRRR! Solution: Make it possible for the defender to improve the fortifications of a city. Method: Probably by expending resources or permanently reducing maximum field army size by constructing improved fortifications; but details are unknown, as yet.
In the current rules, all armies are assumed to have the same abilities in siegecraft. No way. That's bogus! Solution: Make a simple system to demonstrate differences in siegecraft abilities of different armies. Method: Unknown. But I hear Knights don't like to dig (!!! that's DIRT, my Lord!!!) so maybe moats are a good defense against Knights, for example.
There will be a simple resource management. Strategic maps (England, Scotland, Ireland, France, Germany, Italy, India, China, Near East, Europe) that I have borrowed from Sierra's great computer game, LORDS OF THE REALM 2; stripped to the bare essentials.
As in LORDS OF THE REALM 2, there will be five types of castles:
I have tried to plan castle dimensions so that they fit neatly on the regular 24x24 in. DBA battle board. There will be a few new siege elements: Boiling Oil, Catapults, Battering Rams, and Siege Towers!
For DBA Campaign games, if the player has built a castle in the "county" when the county is attacked the castle must be taken by the attacker's army! This will replace the old die roll used to resolve sieges.
I am also working on some optional rules to make the usual DBA elements more like the Lords of the Realm 2 elements:
At any rate, I appreciate all suggestions and proposals, and will try to include them when I write the rules. Thanks in advance, Jason Ehlers.
Comments and suggestions to JDYahoo@aol.com.
| Top of Page | Rules Variants | Home |
Last Updated: Nov. 24, 1998Comments and suggestions welcome. Send them to Chris Brantley, IamFanaticus@gmail.com.